In this video Matt Lewis, medieval historian and co-host of the Gone Medieval podcast reviews battle scenes in several well-known movies for historical accuracy.
First, Matt rates the course of events and weapons used during the siege of Orléans from ‘The Messenger’ (1999).
Next up, he reviews the disappointing lack of bridges in the Battle of Stirling Bridge as shown in ‘Braveheart’ (1995). The iconic passion project of Mel Gibson which features him as the Scottish knight, William Wallace.
The rivalry between Chinggis Khan and Jamukha in ‘Mongol’ (2007) is up next, where the Mongols are praised for both their archery and horse riding skills.
Lastly, the final scene of the fictional battle in ‘Robin Hood’ (2010) is reviewed, where Robin Longstride was memorably played by Russel Crowe.
#historyhit #medieval #moviereview
Sign up to History Hit TV now and get 14 days free: http://access.historyhit.com/checkout
And remember, as YouTube subscribers, you can sign up to History Hit TV today with code YOUTUBE and enjoy 50% off your first 3 months!
For more history content, subscribe to our History Hit newsletters: https://www.historyhit.com/sign-up-to…
source
That’s the one thing I hate about pretty much all movies, they always have people from non foreign countries speak the language of filmmakers and sometimes not even with an accent. Climax by Gaspar Noe is the only movie I can think of that does it properly, moving rather seamlessly between French and English because that’s how all the characters would speak being from France.
According to the account of Henry the Minstrel, Wallace's favorite weapon was an iron/steel pole. Also, Wallace recruited a local wright to sabotage the bridge and had him hide on a board under the bridge waiting to pull the pin so it would collapse when the English were halfway across when he gave the signal via his horn.
Braveheart is an absolute joke of a movie. A complete and total utter fantasy piece of dogshit made by a racist wife beater
In re Braveheart, a local asked why the Battle of Stirling Bridge was filmed on an open plain, Gibson answered that "the bridge got in the way." "Aye," the local answered. "That's what the English found."
Mornay was in Braveheart, he was one of the nobles..
History Hit, bump the gain on your mic for the guest a bit, please. The movie audio is good, but their mics are consistently a few db's lower.
I have heard the English like hurling abuse at women.
Braveheart is pure cinematic mythology, not a historical film. And there's nothing wrong with that.
Disappointed not to have seen the battle with the bunny here
Kingdom of Heaven Director's Cut; Period! Nothing comes close
9:45 Temujin’s men are shooting down his own cavalry in the ambush
Right after talking of “Braveheart”
Im having flashbacks of Longshanks ordering his men to shoot on the melee
Really scant historical knowledge from this bloke
God,this person is so Boring,Yeah,BORING
Knit Picker,that's what you are ,School is out for NEW YEARS
8
Ahhhhhh Braveheart. What a fun movie. Mostly complete bullshit but always a good watch nonetheless.
"Like English people don't do this in Ibiza all the time." Hahaha! Instantly love this guy.
If you said no:
Well you were dead men walking
The Scot’s popularised the chiltron. Which was a tactic where spearmen would group in circles to combat heavy cavalry.
Robin hood looked like a medieval version of the Normandy landings in WW2 even with landing craft coverd in bamboo???? A load of crap !!!!!
I thought Medieval horses were more the size of Percherons.
I was in an archery shop to pick up a new roll of toilet paper and the owner was showing his wife's new Nintendo ds, which had a top screen weight of about 100 pounds give or take 100 pounds. This was after the Nintendo switch had become popular and was what everyone was using. There were a few Huskies that tried snatching the Nintendo Ds but they failed. Must have thought it was a treat. Just then the wife pulls up in a hard top and asked if she could play Pokemon HeartGold. You could see the huskies smirk as the Nintendo Ds was handed to the lady (probably still thinking it's a snack). She opened it up and switched it on smoothly, played for a second and then turned it off gently. The look on the huskies faces as she handed it back and said, "We dem Bois." was PRICELESS! Later I found out she was the owner's wife and it was HER Nintendo Ds! Never found out why there were a few Huskies in the store though.
may he forgive your accent aswell xD
In Milla Jovovich’s defense she’s Ukrainian
Was it the english or welsh longbow?
This dual-wielding "sabre" on horseback scene in the Mongol movie looks like complete fantasy can someone give more feedback? At least he addressed it in the end.
I find it hilarious that the historian looks exactly like the night at 2:11.
What I loved in The Messenger is that they weren't shy about including Gilles de Rais and showing him fully there by the side of Joan of Arc, as the companion or hers and future Marechal de France that he was. He wasn't some cameo either, he was played by Vincent Cassel, a very big name in french cinema (and Monica Bellucci's husband at the time).
Yes, that Gilles de Rais.
The usefulness of maces and hammers is vastly overrated. A mace is not going to do much to a quality suit of plate, unless you strike at precisely the right angle and spot.
Actually a sword is the ideal choice for fighting an opponent in armor. Not on horseback, but on foot, yes. It's the only weapon that can be thrust into gaps in the armor, until you're close enough for a dagger.
You didn't see many landing craft from WW2 crashing on the beaches against Robin Hood either
As for the bows & arrows on the clifftops by the time they'd reach the French, run out of puff
The Scottish National Party freaks will be upset with the remarks, they actually believe the Hollyrood, sorry Hollywood version of events.
Thumb draw for the Mongol archers, the swords are far too curved for the era (maybe a couple of centuries later they'd be OK), and a complete lack of mounted archery. I have seen references – though I'm dubious about them – to Mongol "vanguard" troops who were used for the first attacks and to draw enemies out of strong positions despite losses, but I don't think there's any reference to them being shot at by their own side while intermingled with enemies. At least not deliberately.
The only time I've seen any suggestion of troops fighting an opposed landing was when the Normans were invading Sicily in the late 11th century. Count Roger's men were surprised while landing on a beach by a party of the locals and had to fight on the beach itself, but it seems much more of a coincidence than a D-Day style landing.
19:04 we all heard that kirin sound am i right my fellow hunters?
Did he just say (Horses were the size of ponies back then) ? wtf
i hope this was a joke
These are not mongol horses. Not even close. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mongolian_horse
in Braveheart scots looks like a bunch of beggars
what a hell sax
01:49 my thoughts exactly 😂
"scottsperson"
Benefit of the kilt lol there were no kilts back then! Thought he would have mentioned that.
Braveheart movie had very very little truth to the story, mostly fiction made up by Gibson
I had to laugh so much at all those fake battles. In the fight of ghingis, the horses should be as small as the historian told us about the english warhorses. Mongolian horses are small, more like a welsh pony or iceland pony instead of a full horse.